Read the transcript
SPEAKER_00: Do you feel
compelled to overeat but wish
that you could stop?
Or perhaps you know that your
emotions drive your eating, but
you don't really know what to do
about it.
I talk about the side of
overeating that nobody really
talks about.
The emotional and the
psychological side.
There are reasons why you can't
stop eating, and that's what we
explore here.
Here we'll support you on your
journey of awareness to stopping
binge eating altogether.
I am your host, Shelley
Treacher.
Welcome.
Today I'm talking about
realistic New Year's resolutions
for the emotional eater.
I started my year on day one
thinking this year I'm gonna
work less and do other things
that I enjoy more.
How many of us start the year
with something like this?
And then by day five, I return
to work and I completely failed
to stop before nine o'clock in
the evening.
And how many of us fail pretty
quickly with New Year's
resolutions?
They're just not realistic.
That's they're very hopeful, but
it's kind of a brainwashing.
So today I'm going to talk to
you about what you can actually
realistically do this year to
help you with the things that
you really want to achieve.
Traditionally, we take an
inventory of our lives and
decide in January to cut out
what's harmful and to replace it
with what's healthy.
As you know, that rarely lasts,
and the reasons for this are:
well, the first is it took a
lifetime to build and groove
these kinds of habits or neural
network pathways, so it's going
to take some work to undo that
old pattern, replace it with a
new one, and practice it enough
so that it sticks.
And then B, you're still being
influenced by all the reasons
that you did those things in the
first place.
As I've talked about in one of
my first podcasts, there are a
lot of reasons why this happens.
From biology, genetics,
ancestry, to cultural attitudes,
the psychological manipulation
behind buying products, and the
feelings that you have behind
the harmful habits.
So, unless you're paying very
close attention to your
unconscious, which, you know,
most of us aren't, or your daily
life has changed dramatically in
the last month, which, you know,
the only drama is that we're in
lockdown again.
Not at not all that unusual,
really.
And the feelings you have behind
the harmful habits have
completely changed.
Unless all of this has changed,
then you're kind of highly
unlikely, especially in the
situation we're in in the world
right now, you're highly
unlikely to quit the thing that
you've done for years.
So and so this year, of course,
it you know, it's kind of
special.
Already this year there's been
devastating news around the
world.
We've been thrown pretty quickly
back into stress and hardship
after the break of Christmas and
the new start in January.
Lots of people are having to
work and look after the kids and
homeschool at the same time.
Some of the teachers are having
to do that.
I can't imagine how hard that
must be.
So my my kudos goes out to you
if you're a teacher and a
parent.
But all of us are struggling,
all of us are bored, all of us
are doing the same thing every
day, or are stressed out,
working too hard, trying to get
the money in, trying to make
everybody happy, and then at the
end of the day not really having
a lot of pleasure or fun just
for ourselves.
So that's kind of what I'm
basing my realistic New Year's
resolutions around.
But there are still things that
you can realistically do to set
yourself up for the best in
2021.
Like you, all of us, I want a
happy life with a fit body and
good relationships.
So today I thought I'd revisit
some basics and make it clear
what's going to help you gain
control of eating in 2021.
So that you have the best chance
possible of success.
The first thing on my list is to
explore your why.
Identify what really matters to
you, even if it takes some
effort, some time, and some
research.
You need to know and to be able
to remember why you want to stop
eating.
This knowledge needs to be as
deeply grooved in your brain as
the habit of overeating itself,
so it's going to take some
practice.
This is the thing that's going
to make you choose to behave
differently.
Beyond why you want to stop
eating, it's also going to be
relevant and helpful to
understand what you value in any
area of your life.
One reason you eat too much
might be because you're filling
your life with things that
aren't actually that important
to you.
Are there things or people in
your life that you could do
without?
And number two, reflect on when
you binge.
Start to keep a diary or common
themes around your eating.
This can include when you eat
and what habits you have around
the eating.
Binge eating is a habit.
Overeating is usually something
that was learned very early on
and has been practiced, perhaps
interspersed with periods of
dieting, for a long time.
Lots of habits can form around
it.
So notice what kind of habits
you have or what associations
you have with eating junk food.
When do you actually overeat?
Is it when you finish work?
Is it late at night?
When you're on your own, or is
it when you are around a certain
person or in a certain
situation?
This is a common one.
Another common one is
associating celebrations with
cake, lots of junk food, or do
you go to the petrol station,
always buy yourself a coffee or
a chocolate bar?
Or do you eat sweets or go to
the cupboard or binge on
biscuits after dinner while
you're watching telly?
And how long have you had these
habits?
If you want to drop in the
comments when your habit is,
what you do, I would love, love,
love to hear about it.
And I can guarantee that it will
be relatable by somebody else
who's gonna feel better because
somebody else has the same
thing.
Number four is an old favourite,
and this is one that you've
really got to be doing.
So start practicing asking
what's happening just before you
binge eat.
What are you thinking and what
are you feeling?
In order to really start making
changes to your habits, you need
to understand why they're there
in the first place and what
purpose they serve for you.
With overeating, you need to
understand what's making you eat
the way you do.
A large part of this, of course,
will be brainwashing and habit,
but as we've been talking about
for a few months now, it runs
much deeper than that.
There's often discomfort behind
overeating, hence the term
comfort eating.
Usually overeating is a response
to a feeling that you don't know
what else to do with, or that
you're afraid to feel.
We aren't taught very well in
this culture in England and in
many other cultures how to
respond to how we feel.
You may not know how you feel
because you overeat before you
can even discover it.
So trace it backwards.
What were you feeling just
before you ate?
And just before that, and just
before that?
And trace it right back to when
you felt okay.
How did you get from feeling
okay to binge eating?
What thoughts, what feelings,
what came into your head?
How long have you felt that way?
Are you tired and frustrated
because you've done too many
things?
Does something trigger you off
into upset that you squash
because you feel stupid?
Are you angry when your partner
makes a snippy remark but you
swallow it for fear of conflict?
Or are you miserable because you
haven't had any good contact
with anyone lately?
All of these are really normal
everyday human experiences,
especially right now.
We're taking everything too
sensitively right now because
it's the only contact we've got.
So just reflect on what is it
that you're triggered by, how
are you feeling.
The fourth resolution, again,
this is a really good one and
quite a favourite if you're
gonna give up the binge eating,
is to note any self-criticism.
This one can take a long time to
build up a practice and a habit
for to recognise when you're
putting yourself down.
But I can pretty much guarantee
that if you just stop, stop
yourself at any point in the day
and reflect back on what you're
thinking about yourself, there
might be some self-criticism in
there.
So this is a good way to
approach it if you have
absolutely no idea whether
you're criticizing yourself or
not.
But self-criticism will only
make you want to eat more.
And it would give you good
reason to ditch the healthy
habits, or you'd think you have
good reason.
So watch out for thoughts and
behaviours like this.
I'll be fat anyway, I don't
care, I don't care about myself
anyway.
Why can't I stop eating?
There must be something wrong
with me.
Or comparing yourself to others,
or perceiving only negative
things about yourself and
feeling not good enough, feeling
guilty, focusing on the
negative, or punishing yourself.
As I say, these are really very
common behind comfort eating, so
there's something that you need
to get a handle on.
I'd also really love to hear the
critic that you've identified if
you want to put that in the
comments as well.
Again, somebody else is gonna
go, yep, that's me, I say that,
and I guarantee there'll be a
hundred more for where that one
came from.
Resolution four is about
identifying your brainwashing.
So really getting to know how
you convince yourself that it's
okay to eat.
There's really a lot of
brainwashing and self-sabotage
that happens around emotional
binge eating.
Here's some examples.
I'll let myself go now at
Christmas, I can start again in
January.
Or I might as well eat now as
it's here and then tomorrow I
won't buy anymore.
The diet can start tomorrow.
Or if I don't give in to this
urge, I'll just think about it
all the time until I give in.
Or I need this.
Or it's too late for me.
All of these are the ways that
you tell yourself that it's okay
to carry on comfort eating and
staying in your comfort zone.
Here's the real truth to those
statements.
You won't be able to be any
different tomorrow or in January
because you won't have addressed
the cause of your eating and how
to manage that, like I said at
the beginning.
And the effect on your health
actually is a lot more of a
waste than dumping any cake or
junk food And how long have you
tried denying a binge for?
Without being on a diet or
starving yourself?
If the desire to eat does stay
with you, so what?
What are you dealing with there?
What's the worst that could
actually happen?
How could you be viewing this as
an opportunity to understand
that it's discomfort that causes
you to eat?
As a starting point for
discovery.
As soon as you have certain
foods like sugar and fat, you'll
immediately crave more.
They're addictive in their
chemistry.
The people who make them know
that.
But the physical craving
actually subsides pretty
quickly.
It's the emotional and
psychological craving that's way
more deeply rooted and
complicated.
So you really need to start
getting to know that.
The emotion, but also how you're
kidding yourself that it's not
emotion and that you just like
it.
You actually really don't need
this addictive, dangerous
substance.
You're choosing to eat it
because you don't know how else
to soothe how you feel, or you
aren't taking the time to allow
any other solution.
The food doesn't actually help
you in the end.
It won't take away the feeling
you have behind it for long or
fix the real problem.
And that's not to say that I'm
asking you to stop eating, to
stop junk food.
I'm not here to say that.
In fact, in any of my programs,
wherever I work with people,
that is not on my agenda.
But I do think that if you start
to think about things
differently and alter how you're
feeling and what's going on for
you and how you address your
emotions, then things are going
to start changing anyway.
And that's the idea to begin
like this and end 2021 with a
different habit.
So that brings us to number six,
responding to your needs, to
your feelings and the problem
differently.
In this podcast, I've talked
about three different ways to do
that.
You can use self-soothing
techniques like meditation,
mindfulness, and visualization.
All of these help you get into a
different state of mind.
With the mania of craving food
and with the feelings behind the
desire to eat, this is often
what's needed.
It's easy to find these kinds of
techniques for free online.
If you're not sure where to
start, a favourite of mine is
Kristen Neff on self-compassion.
What these techniques do is they
get you into a certain part of
your brain that is rational,
rational, reasonable,
compassionate, and adult.
It's literally a different part
of your brain to the feeling or
instinctual part.
It's the part of you that can
look after you, stand up for
you, and make good choices for
your well-being.
Self-soothing also calms your
physiological system down, which
is something that you might also
want to notice.
Your physiological system is
probably in a quite of a
stressed state or a certain kind
of state when you eat.
And the second technique I've
talked about is self-nurture.
The comfort eater is often
eating in response to an inner
critic.
The words that we mentioned
before, I'm so fat, I don't
matter anyway, I never get it
right, I'm not good enough,
nobody listens to me, shut up,
you stupid cow.
So you need to develop an inner
nurturer who really, really
loves you.
What about trying to understand
the reasons that you feel or act
the way you do?
Just like you would with
somebody that you love.
So continue to ask yourself what
you feel, to understand your
feelings and what you really
need.
And here's a little way that you
can do that.
So treat yourself as if you were
somebody that you feel really
affectionate towards and just
ask yourself how you're feeling.
So, sweetheart, how are you
feeling?
And then respond from that
person's point of view and say,
I'm feeling sad, or whatever it
is that you're feeling.
And then when you've done that,
reflect back that you've heard
that feeling.
Oh, sweetheart, I hear that
you're feeling sad.
And then carry that conversation
on with as many feelings as
you've got, as many as you can
come up with, and then ask what
you need in the same way.
This is a really nice way to
practice this if you're not used
to asking yourself how you feel.
And it might sound strange at
first, speaking in third person,
but it's really effective.
And sometimes you do just need
to go deeper to find out how
you're feeling and what you
need.
It takes time to learn how to
trust your feelings,
particularly as is often the
case, some kind of trauma caused
you to block them off in the
first place.
This is something you may need
professional help with.
Identifying and managing
feelings can be really
challenging for the emotional
eater, so it is important that
you acknowledge that this grows
and develops gradually.
So now I just want to say a
little bit about
procrastination.
In my groups, I often ask what
people want me to write or talk
about, and I was asked to talk
about procrastination.
So I thought this would be a
good thing to mention in
January.
My first response to the request
is to ask whether even asking
the question involves
self-judgment or self-criticism.
Just like binge eating,
procrastination is often a way
to manage overwhelm, anxiety, or
depression.
It could be a natural unhealthy
response to burnout.
So the real question and
exploration is what is the
procrastination for you?
Then the way to deal with
procrastination becomes a very
different thing to using
willpower.
Just like with binge eating,
learning to rest and manage
stress becomes the real
solution.
I also want to mention
dissociation.
It's a big subject, so I'm not
going to go into massive detail
in it, but just to say what's so
great about being busy all the
time anyway.
Keeping busy can be a way of
dissociating from pain and
challenge, just like binge
eating.
We naturally chase pleasure or
reward at any time, but being
deprived of our usual outlets
for this at the moment and with
the challenges that we face with
COVID-19, it's not easy to be
doing anything else right now.
Dissociation is often caused by
avoiding the pain or challenge
of difficulty or trauma.
It can show up as distance from
your own feelings and thoughts,
numbness, coldness, or
blankness, which then can
develop into a habit or an
addiction in itself.
You can see how other addictions
jump on board here to support
dissociation.
Binge eating in itself can make
you numb or feel pleasure.
So what's the way out?
In this podcast, what I've
suggested is that you explore
your values, your discomfort,
your automatic thoughts, and
find other ways to manage your
habits and discomfort.
Just as a starting block in not
being asked to give up any of
the things that help you to feel
better in the day, but just to
start exploring something
different.
Stopping emotional eating is a
constant journey of awareness.
There isn't a quick fix or cure
because there is none for the
discomfort of being human.
Revisiting engagement is where
you'll find relief and change.
The more often you come back to
what's important to you,
engaging with what you're doing,
how you feel, and what you need,
the more you're likely to choose
what's really best for you.
So that's what I have to say
today.
I would really welcome your
comments, especially if you
found anything useful.
Let me know what you found
helpful, but also let me know
what you'd like me to talk
about.
You can comment here, or you can
find my Facebook support group,
Comfort Eating Recovery Support
Group.
Or if you want to go a lot
further, look at my details at
bristolcounselling.co.uk.
At the moment I'm gathering
participants for the next group
at the end of January, beginning
of February.
There are a couple of places
left, so please get in touch.
Thank you for listening.
Happy New Year.